Which Brand Is Making the Best Bacon?
On February 25, 2026 By newsroom Topic: Food Guide
Consumer Reports tested a variety of bacon brands, from pork to turkey and uncooked to precooked, revealing the standout options and insights.
Top-Rated Bacon: Kirkland Signature Regular
- Why It’s Best:
- Crisped perfectly with balanced fat and meat flavors.
- Smoky with a hint of sweetness.
- Availability:
- Sold in bulk (four 1-pound packages) — ideal for freezing.
- Cooking Tip:
- Store opened packages in the fridge for up to a week.
Very Good Alternatives
Great Value Lower Sodium (Walmart)
- A less salty option that doesn’t compromise flavor.
Oscar Mayer Thick Cut
- Thicker slices for heartier bites.
Turkey Bacon Findings
- Taste:
- Lower fat but lacked the rich flavors of pork bacon.
- Strong liquid smoke flavor.
- Texture:
- Uniform, re-formed slices.
Verdict: Choose only if health considerations are a priority.
Precooked Bacon Results
- Less flavorful and crisp compared to regular uncooked options.
- Oscar Mayer Fully Cooked:
- Bland when eaten straight.
- Crisping during cooking defeats its purpose.
Cooking Methods for the Best Bacon
- Microwave: Quick and convenient.
- Pan-frying: Best for controlling crispness.
- Broiling/Baking: Perfect for large batches.
Bacon Insights and Claims Explained
- Nitrites and Nitrates:
- Common curing agents that enhance flavor and color but may form potentially harmful nitrosamines.
- No Antibiotics:
- Niman Ranch is the only tested brand raising pigs without antibiotics.
- Thick Cut:
- More satisfying slices; one slice equals two regular servings.
- Uncured:
- Uses natural nitrites (e.g., celery powder) instead of synthetic ones, as seen in Trader Joe's and Niman Ranch.
Summing it up
For the Best Experience: Stick with Kirkland Signature Regular.
Health-Conscious Choice: Consider Great Value Lower Sodium or Niman Ranch for antibiotic-free options.
Cooking Preferences Matter: The right method can raise any bacon’s flavor and texture.
Enjoy bacon occasionally for a satisfying treat, but be mindful of portions and preparation!
