Should You Repair or Replace Your Broken Washing Machine?
On February 16, 2025 By newsroom Topic: Appliance Buyers Guide
When your washing machine stops working, deciding whether to repair or replace it depends on age, cost, and the nature of the problem. Here's a guide to help you make the best decision.
Key Factors to Consider
Age of the Washer
- Average washer lifespan: 10 years.
- A younger washer is often worth repairing; an older washer (7+ years) may warrant replacement.
Cost Analysis
- If the repair costs 50% or more of the original price, replacement is often the better choice.
- New washers offer better energy efficiency, which can save money in the long run.
Repair Costs by Washer Type (Median Costs)
- Top-Load Agitator: $129
- Top-Load HE: $165
- Front-Load: $171
- Typical service call fee: $100–$150 (applied to the repair cost).
Common Washer Problems
Issues That May Require Repair
- Control panel malfunction.
- Water drainage problems.
- Vibrations or imbalance during spin cycles.
- Drum not spinning.
- Leaks or clogged drain pumps.
Minor DIY Repairs
- Replacing a broken button or knob.
- Cleaning the filter or balancing the load.
Complex problems like replacing a motor or drum bearings often require professional help due to the specialized tools and skills needed.
When to Repair or Replace
Repair if:
- Washer is under 5 years old.
- The repair cost is less than 50% of the original price.
- Problem is minor (e.g., clogged drain or small part replacement).
Replace if:
- Washer is 7+ years old and repair costs are high.
- Repair costs exceed 50% of the original purchase price.
- Your current washer no longer meets your needs (capacity, efficiency, or features).
Research and Warranty Tips
Check for Manufacturer's Warranty
- Most washers have a 1-year warranty, but brands like Speed Queen offer extended coverage (up to 7 years).
Search for Recalls or Common Issues
- Check the manufacturer’s website for known issues or updates.
Self-Diagnosis Tools
- Many modern washers have Wi-Fi diagnostic features or troubleshooting apps that can help identify problems.
Online Resources
- Platforms like YouTube or brand-specific forums can provide insights or minor repair guides.
Environmental Considerations
- Recycling Options: Contact your local waste management or use tools like Earth911 to find nearby recycling centers.
- Green Choice Models: Upgrade to a washer that uses less water and energy.
Finding a Repair Technician
Who to Call
- Independent Repair Shops: Handle 53% of repairs, with high satisfaction rates.
- Retailers: Often manage repairs for appliances purchased in their stores.
- Manufacturers: May cover warranty or recall-related repairs.
Success Rates
- Professional repairs are successful 91% of the time, though 19% may require follow-ups.
Top-Rated Washers to Consider if Replacing
Front-Load Washers
- Best for energy and water efficiency.
High-Efficiency (HE) Top-Load Washers
- Gentle on clothes and save water.
Agitator Top-Load Washers
- Reliable for heavy-duty cleaning.
Tip: Refer to Experts' Washing Machine Ratings for reliable, eco-friendly models.
Summary
- Repair if: Washer is younger, repair costs are low, and the issue is minor.
- Replace if: Washer is older, repair costs are high, or it’s inefficient by today’s standards.
- Eco-Friendly Tip: Recycle your old washer and consider upgrading to an energy-efficient model for long-term savings.
Stay informed, and make the decision that works best for your household and budget.
