What to Do If a Car Insurance Company Won’t Cover Your Vehicle?

On February 25, 2026  By newsroom   Topic: Automotive

Certain cars, especially those prone to theft or considered high-risk, may be denied coverage by insurers. If you find yourself in this situation, here’s how to navigate the challenges:


Why Some Cars Are Denied Coverage

High Theft Risk:
- Models with high theft rates, like some Hyundais and Kias, may be harder to insure.

High-Performance or Collector Cars:
- Sports cars like the Corvette or vintage collectibles often fall into the "unacceptable risk" category due to repair costs or limited availability of parts.

Driver Risk Profile:
- Insurers consider factors such as:
- Age, gender, and driving record
- Location, especially high-traffic or crash-prone areas

Rising Insurance Costs:
- Increasing claims, distracted driving, and costly repairs have caused premiums to rise 26% on average over the past year.


Steps to Take If You’re Denied Coverage

Widen Your Search
- Most mass-market cars are covered by major insurers, so shop around to find one willing to insure your vehicle.

Consider Specialty Insurers
- If you own a high-performance or collector car, look for specialty policies tailored to these vehicles.
- These policies may use agreed-upon car values and set annual mileage limits.

Assigned Risk Pools
- If you can’t secure traditional coverage:
- Use an assigned risk pool, a last-resort option managed by AIPSO (Find a Producer).
- Be prepared to pay significantly higher premiums (up to 50% more).

Check Coverage Before Buying
- Research potential insurance costs and availability for the car model you’re considering before making a purchase.


Tips for Avoiding Insurance Issues

  • Research Theft Rates: Avoid vehicles with high theft rates unless you’re ready to pay more for insurance.
  • Maintain a Clean Driving Record: Drive safely to lower your risk profile.
  • Consider Usage-Based Policies: High-end or collector cars often qualify for policies with mileage limits.

The Bottom Line

  • Most mass-market vehicles are insurable, though costs vary widely.
  • Shopping around and understanding your vehicle’s risk profile can save you headaches.
  • If all else fails, specialty insurers or assigned risk programs can ensure you’re covered.

Pro Tip: Use tools like car insurance ratings to compare insurers and find the best option for your situation.


Next: Read 2500+ consumer guides to shopping, electronics, appliances, home services, cars, money and more.
If you liked all this, consider supporting us by checking out SkillThing DOING Manuals

DOING Manuals


The AI Proof Career

Future-proof your work in the AI age.


31 Days to Escaping Job Search Hell

Escape job search hell right out of college. Get job-ready in 31 days.