On February 16, 2025 By newsroom Topic: Food Guide
Artificial sweeteners like aspartame, sucralose, and stevia extracts are increasingly found in everyday foods beyond diet sodas, including yogurts, oatmeal, and even popcorn. But are they a healthier alternative to sugarHere’s what the research says.
Non-Nutritive Sweeteners (NNS):
- Provide little to no calories or nutrients.
- Includes aspartame, sucralose, Ace-K, saccharin, stevia extracts, and monkfruit.
- Stevia and monkfruit are considered “natural” but undergo heavy processing.
Sugar Alcohols:
- Examples: Sorbitol, xylitol, mannitol.
- Contain carbs and calories but fewer than sugar.
FDA Approval and Safety:
- Sweeteners like aspartame have Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI) limits.
- Example: A 160-pound adult can safely consume up to 3,680 mg of aspartame daily (~18 cans of diet soda).
Potential Risks Below ADI Levels:
- Increased risk for type 2 diabetes, metabolic syndrome, cancer, and heart disease.
- Example: A 2019 Stroke study found women drinking 24+ ounces of diet soda daily had:
- 35% higher risk of heart disease.
- 26% higher stroke risk.
- 19% increased risk of early death.
Observational Studies’ Limitations:
- Most studies are observational, meaning they show associations but cannot prove causation.
Emerging data suggest risks may vary by sweetener type:
- Aspartame and Ace-K:
- Linked to higher cancer and stroke risks.
- Sucralose and Ace-K:
- Associated with increased heart disease risk.
Why the Differences?
- Variations in metabolism and effects on the gut microbiome or inflammation.
Inconsistent Results:
- BMJ 2019 Review: 56 studies found no consistent weight loss among users.
- Canadian Medical Association Journal (2017): Long-term use may even promote weight gain.
Short-Term Benefits:
- A 2020 study found switching from sugary to NNS drinks helped reduce weight and body fat, especially in people with abdominal obesity.
Moderation is Key:
- Occasional use is fine, especially to transition away from sugary drinks.
- Avoid making artificially sweetened foods and drinks a daily habit.
Focus on Overall Diet:
- Prioritize vegetables, nuts, legumes, and reducing alcohol, red meat, and processed foods for long-term health benefits over worrying solely about NNS.