Cracking your phone screen is frustrating, but deciding whether to repair it or buy a new phone depends on several factors. Here’s a guide to help you make the right choice.

When to Replace the Phone Screen

Cost-Effectiveness
- Screen repair is typically cheaper than buying a new phone.
- Example: Replacing an iPhone SE screen costs $129, while a new phone costs at least $599.

Insurance or Extended Warranty
- AppleCare+ and Samsung Care+ offer screen repairs for $29.
- Note coverage limitations: AppleCare+ allows up to two accidental damage claims per year.

Device Age and Functionality
- If the phone is still modern, fast, and reliable, repairing it can extend its lifespan by 1–2 years.

Repair Options
- Authorized Repair Centers: Reliable but may cost more.
- Third-Party Services: Often cheaper but can void warranties or compromise quality.
- Examples: UBreakiFix and Swappa offer cost estimates online.

When to Buy a New Phone

Cost of Repair vs. Phone Value
- If the repair costs more than the phone's resale or trade-in value, upgrading may be wiser.
- Example: Fixing an iPhone 5s screen costs $129, while the phone’s value is less than $75.

Outdated Security Updates
- Phones no longer receiving security updates are vulnerable to cyber threats.
- Apple supports models back to the iPhone 5s for security patches, but older Android models may not qualify.

Time Sensitivity
- Same-day repairs aren’t always available, and parts may be out of stock.
- If you can’t be without a phone for long, it might be time to upgrade.

Phone Condition
- If the phone is slow, crashing, or experiencing battery issues, a new phone is likely a better investment.

Repair Costs by Model

• iPhone SE (4.7-inch screen): $129
• iPhone 14 Pro Max (6.7-inch screen): $379
• Samsung Galaxy S series: Costs vary; check Samsung’s repair pricing.

Upgrade Alternatives

• Refurbished Phones: Save money on slightly older models (e.g., iPhone 12 for $599).
• Carrier Deals: Some providers offer free upgrades with trade-ins, even for damaged phones.

Summing it up

• Repair the screen if the phone is relatively new, repair costs are reasonable, or you have insurance.
• Replace the phone if it’s outdated, lacks security updates, or is on its last legs.

Pro Tip: Always compare repair quotes with your phone’s resale value and the cost of a new model to determine the best option.

Next: Read 2500+ consumer guides to shopping, electronics, appliances, home services, cars, money and more.

❤ If you liked all this, consider supporting us by checking out SkillThing DOING Manuals