On February 16, 2025 By newsroom Topic: Technology Buyers Guide
Voice assistants like Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa are becoming staples in many homes, but they come with privacy concerns. New research reveals how these devices use your voice interactions to create targeted ads and adjust responses based on inferred user profiles.
Voice Data Usage:
- Google Assistant: Profiles users based on voice interactions, inferring demographics (e.g., marital status, homeowner status) and interests.
- Amazon Alexa: Tags users with product categories based on shopping actions (e.g., adding items to a cart) rather than conversational interactions.
- Apple Siri: Does not connect user data to an advertising profile and doesn’t use voice data for targeted ads.
Targeted Ads:
- Google: Uses inferred profiles to influence ads across Google platforms (Search, Gmail, YouTube) and websites in its ad network.
- Amazon: Suggests ads on its platforms (e.g., Amazon.com, Fire TV) based on shopping behaviors.
- Apple: Minimal ad targeting, relying only on account details and in-app behavior.
Data Collection:
- Google uses voice commands to infer user details (e.g., asking about "family trip destinations" might suggest marital status).
- Amazon tracks actions like adding items to a cart to tag users with shopping interests.
Ad Customization:
- Google adjusts responses and ads based on user profiles. For instance:
- A "married homeowner" might get restaurant recommendations for expensive venues.
- A "single renter" might get budget-friendly options nearby.
- Amazon recommends similar items based on prior shopping behaviors.
Apple provides more privacy by not linking Siri interactions to user profiles.
Behavioral Changes:
Google Assistant’s responses may vary based on user profiles, potentially affecting search results or recommendations.
Broader Implications:
Review Your Profile:
- Google: Check your ad preferences at the My Ad Center and edit or delete incorrect tags.
- Amazon: Review shopping-related tags in your account’s user data download.
Opt Out of Targeted Ads:
- Stop Google and Amazon from using your profile for ad targeting. This won’t eliminate ads but will make them less personalized.
Enhance Privacy Settings:
- Adjust privacy settings for voice assistants. .
Consider Siri:
- For privacy-conscious users, Apple Siri is the most privacy-friendly option as it doesn’t use voice interactions for profiling.
While voice assistants provide convenience, they also collect data that may be used to target ads or modify responses. Knowing how each platform operates helps you make informed decisions to protect your privacy.