Homeowners Insurance Buying Guide
On February 16, 2025 By newsroom Topic: Insurance Basics
Why Homeowners Insurance Costs Are Rising
Rising Construction Costs:
- Shortages in building materials and skilled labor have driven up repair/rebuild expenses.
- Cement, drywall, and lumber prices remain higher than pre-pandemic levels.
Natural Disasters:
- Hurricanes, floods, and wildfires increase demand for materials and labor, raising costs.
- Higher risks in disaster-prone areas lead to premium hikes even for claim-free homeowners.
Fraud and Litigation:
- Lawsuits, particularly in states like Florida, contribute to inflated insurance rates.
Increased Claims:
- Frequent catastrophes lead to insurers exiting certain markets, reducing competition and raising premiums.
How to Find a Good Homeowners Insurer
Check Satisfaction Ratings:
- Look for companies with high scores for claims handling, premiums, and customer service.
- Top-rated insurers: USAA, NJM, Amica (some require direct applications).
Comparison Tools:
- Use state insurance department tools for rate comparisons.
- Try sites like Insure.com, NetQuote, and SelectQuote for quotes.
Independent Agents:
- Agents can provide quotes from multiple insurers to help find the best fit.
How Much Coverage Do You Need?
- Rebuild Value:
- Insure for the cost to rebuild, not market value (which includes land).
- Loss of Use Coverage:
- Covers temporary housing costs during repairs—review this with your agent to ensure adequate limits.
Optional Add-Ons to Consider
Extended Replacement Cost:
- Covers rebuild costs exceeding policy limits (20–25% higher).
Inflation Protection:
- Automatically adjusts coverage limits to reflect rising construction costs.
Disaster-Specific Coverage:
- Separate policies or add-ons for earthquakes, hail, windstorms, or floods.
Contents Replacement Cost:
- Ensures reimbursement for replacing damaged/stolen items without depreciation.
Valuables Protection:
- Add "floaters" for items like jewelry, furs, and firearms exceeding standard limits.
Sewer Backup:
- Covers damage from sewage backups or sump-pump failures.
Ways to Save on Homeowners Insurance
Bundle Policies:
- Combine home and auto insurance for discounts of up to 30%.
Raise Your Deductible:
- Opting for a $1,000 deductible (vs. $500) can significantly reduce premiums.
Home Improvements:
- Install security systems, upgrade plumbing, and replace old roofs for discounts.
When to Avoid Filing a Claim
- Filing frequent or small claims can lead to premium hikes or nonrenewals.
- Avoid claims for minor damages slightly above your deductible.
What to Do If Your Policy Is Canceled or Not Renewed
- Cancellation:
- Can happen within the first 60 days for any reason; afterward, usually for nonpayment or increased risk.
- Nonrenewal:
- Common reasons include too many claims or insurers exiting the area.
Steps to Take:
-
Contact your state’s insurance department for available insurers.
-
Consider state-sponsored high-risk insurance pools (FAIR Plans).
Additional Insurance to Consider
- Flood Insurance:
- A necessity even in low-risk zones. Standard policies don’t cover flooding from external sources.
-
Average premium: $688 annually (low-risk areas); $838 (high-risk).
-
Umbrella Liability Insurance:
- Extends liability coverage beyond standard policy limits, covering lawsuits for libel, slander, and more.
Homeowners Insurance Ratings
- Survey-based ratings include claims handling, premiums, service, advice, and coverage clarity.
- Satisfaction levels reflect real consumer experiences for insights into insurer performance.
By understanding your coverage needs and actively comparing options, you can secure a policy that balances cost, protection, and peace of mind.
