This research offers an in-depth analysis of health insurance options in India, focusing on base cover and super top-up policies. It evaluates plans based on coverage, cost, claim ratios, and other key features.
1. Key Filters for a Good Health Policy:
- No Co-Pay: Avoid policies that require you to share a portion of the hospital bill.
- No Room Rent Limit: Look for single private AC room coverage or no cap.
- No Sublimits: Policies should not restrict coverage for specific surgeries.
- Reset Benefit: Ability to restore the sum insured for future claims in the same year.
- Claims Paid Ratio > 85%: Higher claim settlement ratios indicate reliability.
- Hospital Network: Ensure a strong network of empaneled hospitals near your location.
2. Summary of Findings by Insurer:
ICICI Lombard
- Base Policy:
- Sublimit for surgeries in 5L cover but not for 7L+ cover.
- Limited pre/post-hospitalization (30/60 days).
- Super Top-Up:
- Excellent with no major drawbacks.
- Claims Paid Ratio: 88% (average).
- Premium: Slightly high.
Max Bupa (ReAssure + Recharge)
- Base and Super Top-Up Policies:
- Cheaper than competitors but suspiciously so.
- Incurred Claim Ratio: 53% (low).
- Possible partial claims approval to inflate claims paid ratio (91%).
- Complaints: High complaints per 10,000 claims.
Star Health (Comprehensive + Super Surplus)
- Features:
- OPD and dental coverage included.
- Single private AC room cap.
- Claims Paid Ratio: 81% (low).
- Complaints: High complaint frequency.
- Cost: Higher than competitors.
HDFC Ergo (Optima Restore + Medisure Super Top-Up)
- Base Policy:
- Excellent features but slightly expensive.
- Super Top-Up:
- Max cover capped at 20L.
- Claims Paid Ratio: 97% (excellent).
- Hospital Network: Extensive.
Manipal Cigna (ProHealth + Super Top-Up)
- Base Policy:
- Good features at an affordable price.
- Super Top-Up:
- Max cover limited to 30L.
- Incurred Claim Ratio: 61% (low).
- Complaints: Moderately high.
Religare (Care Health + Enhance)
- Features:
- Affordable and comprehensive base policy.
- Super top-up max cover at 30L.
- Claims Paid Ratio: 94%.
- Incurred Claim Ratio: 59% (low).
New India (Premier Mediclaim + Top-Up)
- Base Policy:
- Room rent cap in 5L plan; 15L plan has no issues but is very costly.
- Super Top-Up:
- Not available. Top-up max cover limited to 22L.
- Hospital Network: Limited.
Royal Sundaram (Lifeline Supreme)
- Features:
- Excellent base policy at the lowest premium.
- Claims Paid Ratio: 95%.
- Super Top-Up: Couldn’t find details online.
Go Digit (Health + Super Top-Up)
- Base Policy:
- Affordable but includes a 4-year waiting period for pre-existing diseases.
- Super Top-Up:
- Max cover of 20L, relatively expensive.
- Claims Paid Ratio: 83%.
- Incurred Claim Ratio: 51% (low).
3. Shortlist:
Based on claims ratio, coverage, and cost, the top contenders are:
- HDFC Ergo (Excellent claim ratio, limited super top-up cover).
- ICICI Lombard (Good overall but average claim ratio).
4. Next Steps Before Finalizing:
- Review Claim Settlement Experience:
- Seek feedback on real-world claim processes for the shortlisted insurers.
- Future Scalability:
- Ensure the policy allows upgrading coverage as needs grow.
- Regional Network:
- Confirm hospital network quality in your area.
5. Conclusion:
- HDFC Ergo stands out for its excellent claim settlement ratio, despite a lower super top-up cap.
- ICICI Lombard is reliable but lags in certain aspects like pre/post-hospitalization limits.
- Policies should be chosen based on individual needs, insurer reputation, and long-term viability.
Next: Read 2500+ consumer guides to shopping, electronics, appliances, home services, cars, money and more.
