Guide to Assessing a Bank’s Riskiness for Your Deposits?
On February 16, 2025 By newsroom Topic: India Money Advice
Key Metrics to Evaluate a Bank’s Stability:
- Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR):
- Measures a bank’s ability to absorb losses.
- Formula:
[ \text{CAR} = (\text{Capital Reserves + Shareholder Funds}) / \text{Risk-Weighted Assets} ] - Healthy CAR: Above 12% (Indian context).
- Red Flag: Lakshmi Vilas Bank had 0.17% as of June 2020.
- Gross NPA (GNPA) & Net NPA (NNPA):
- GNPA: Total percentage of loans gone bad.
- Safe: Below 5%. Red Flag: Over 10%.
- NNPA: GNPA minus provisions set aside for bad loans.
- Safe: Below 3%.
- Example:
- GNPA = (?9 /90) = 10%.
- NNPA = (?9 -3) /90 = 6.67%.
- LVB’s GNPA: 25.4% and NNPA: 9.64% in June 2020!
- Profitability and Revenue Trends:
- Check if the bank is consistently profitable and growing its revenues.
- Persistent losses can erode reserves and impact repayment ability.
- Example:
- LVB’s share price fell from187 in 2017 to12 in 2020 due to continuous losses.
- Contrast with stable, growing banks like HDFC, ICICI, or SBI.
- Prompt Corrective Action (PCA) List:
- What is PCA? RBI monitors banks with weak financial metrics.
- How to check: Google "[Bank Name] PCA" in the news section.
- Action Point: Avoid banks under PCA, as they face operational restrictions.
Practical Steps to Secure Your Deposits:
- Diversify Your Bank Accounts:
- Keep accounts in both private and public banks to reduce risk.
- Public banks (e.g., SBI) ensure access during crises like demonetization.
-
Private banks (e.g., HDFC, ICICI) offer superior service.
-
Prefer Systemically Important Banks (SIBs):
- Tagged as “too big to fail,” these banks are prioritized for RBI bailouts.
-
Examples: SBI, HDFC, ICICI, Kotak.
-
Limit Exposure:
-
For HNIs, open accounts with 2-3 banks to avoid concentration risk.
-
Monitor News:
- Keep an eye out for adverse reports, PCA listings, or declining metrics.
Limitations and Caveats:
- Manipulated Metrics:
- Indian banking audits can miss frauds for years. Numbers may be unreliable.
- Stay alert to sudden news or red flags.
- Example of Frauds:
- Punjab & Maharashtra Co-operative Bank (PMC) faced hidden bad loans worth6,500 crores.
Quick Checklist Before Choosing a Bank:
- CAR > 12%.
- GNPA < 5%; NNPA < 3%.
- Consistent profitability and revenue growth.
- Not under RBI’s PCA framework.
- Strong reputation and market cap (e.g., SBI, HDFC, ICICI).
To sum up:
Choose banks with strong fundamentals, diversify deposits across reliable institutions, and monitor red flags like NPAs or PCA listings. Be proactive to secure uninterrupted access to your funds.
