Diesel vs. Biodiesel vs. Vegetable Oil: Key Insights and Test Results
On February 16, 2025 By newsroom Topic: Automotive
1. Overview of Fuels
- Diesel: The baseline fuel, widely available and suitable for unmodified diesel engines.
- Biodiesel (B5, B20, B100): Derived from vegetable or animal fats, blended with petroleum diesel.
- B5: 5% biodiesel, 95% petroleum diesel.
- B20: 20% biodiesel, 80% petroleum diesel.
- B100: Pure biodiesel, renewable but expensive and less convenient.
- Vegetable Oil: Used fryer oil, often free from restaurants but requires filtering and engine modifications.
2. Performance
| Fuel | Fuel Economy (MPG) | Acceleration (0-60 mph) | Cost |
|-------------------|------------------------|-----------------------------|-----------------------------|
| Diesel | 45 | 15 seconds | Standard price |
| B5 (5%) | 49 (best) | 14.2 seconds (best) | Similar to diesel |
| B100 (100%) | 44 | 15 seconds | $0.85 more per gallon |
| Vegetable Oil| 42 | 15 seconds | Low/free but labor-intensive|
3. Emissions
| Emission Type | Diesel | B5 | B100 | Vegetable Oil |
|---------------------|------------|--------|----------|-------------------|
| Hydrocarbons | 3 ppm | 3 ppm | 9 ppm | 14 ppm |
| NOx (Nitrogen) | Moderate | Moderate| High | Lowest |
| Particulates | Moderate | Moderate| Lowest | Lowest |
| CO2 (Carbon) | ~19 lbs/gal for all fuels, offset claims by biofuels disputed. |
Key Takeaways:
- Biodiesel fuels generally had cleaner emissions than diesel.
- Cooking oil had the lowest NOx and particulate emissions but higher hydrocarbons.
4. Convenience and Practicality
Diesel
- No modifications required.
- Standard fuel stations; widely available.
B5 (5% Biodiesel)
- No engine modifications needed.
- Best balance of performance, fuel economy, and emissions.
- Convenient to use at standard pumps.
B100 (100% Biodiesel)
- Renewable but costly.
- No significant fuel economy or performance advantage over diesel.
- Limited manufacturer warranty coverage beyond B20.
Vegetable Oil
- Renewable and free/low cost but highly labor-intensive:
- Requires finding, filtering, and storing oil.
- Engine modifications needed (e.g., auxiliary tank).
- Additional setup steps before and after driving:
- Start with diesel and purge system after use.
- Can result in diesel mixing with cooking oil if not managed correctly.
5. Modifications for Testing
- Engine Conversion: A $1,550 kit from Greasecar Vegetable Fuel Systems was installed, including:
- A 13-gallon auxiliary tank for vegetable oil.
- Additional fuel lines, inline filters, and switches.
- Installation Time: 10 hours by a certified mechanic.
- Extra Testing Tanks:
- Two additional 5-gallon tanks installed for B100 and B5 fuels.
- Labor for Vegetable Oil: Collecting, filtering, and storing oil required significant effort.
6. Experts' Recommendations
- Best Overall: B5 Biodiesel
- Offers the best balance of convenience, fuel economy, and environmental benefits.
-
Widely supported by automakers for use in diesel engines.
-
Renewable but Challenging: Vegetable Oil
- Suitable for enthusiasts willing to invest time and effort.
-
Requires engine modifications and ongoing maintenance.
-
Not Economical: B100 Biodiesel
-
While renewable, it has no financial advantage and limited warranty coverage.
-
Reliable Choice: Diesel
- Best for users prioritizing availability and simplicity.
7. Conclusion
While diesel remains a practical choice for performance and availability, B5 biodiesel is the most accessible eco-friendly alternative. Vegetable oil is a niche option for dedicated hobbyists, while B100 biodiesel, though renewable, is costly and less convenient.
For a sustainable and hassle-free transition, stick with B5 or B20 blends.
