Crib Mattress Buying Guide

On February 16, 2025 By newsroom Topic: Shopping Skills

Choosing a crib mattress for your baby is simpler than picking out a crib but requires careful attention to safety, firmness, and fit. This guide highlights essential considerations, types of crib mattresses, and extra features to help you make an informed choice.


Key Considerations for Crib Mattresses

1. Safety First

  • Size Guidelines: Must be at least 27¼" wide, 51¼" long, and no more than 6" thick.
  • Snug Fit: Ensure no more than a ½-inch gap between the mattress and crib walls to avoid entrapment.
  • Firmness: Choose a firm mattress that doesn’t sink under the baby’s weight.
  • Memory foam mattresses are NOT suitable.
  • Manufacture Date: Ensure it meets the new safety standards (after August 15, 2022).

2. Simplicity is Best

  • Avoid adding bumpers, blankets, stuffed animals, or pillows to the crib to reduce the risk of suffocation.

Types of Crib Mattresses

1. Foam Mattresses

  • Material: Made from high-density polyurethane foam.
  • Weight: Lighter (8–13 lbs) and easier to handle.
  • Cost: $40–$400.
  • Durability: Less durable than innerspring; replace if it begins to soften or sag.

2. Innerspring Mattresses

  • Material: Steel coils with cotton or foam cushioning.
  • Weight: Heavier (10–20 lbs), sturdier, and more durable.
  • Cost: $60–$1,300.
  • Firmness Factors:
  • Coil Count: More coils = better support (ranges from 80 to 200+).
  • Steel Gauge: Lower numbers mean thicker steel and more firmness.
  • Border Rods: Steel edges provide extra firmness.

3. Hybrid Mattresses

  • Description: Dual-sided for infants (firm) and toddlers (softer).
  • Cost: Higher-end option but versatile for long-term use.
  • Guidance: Follow instructions for when to flip the mattress for toddlers.

Additional Features

1. Crib Mattress Covers

  • Purpose: Protects against leaks, spit-up, and accidents.
  • Waterproof Options: Vinyl covers are effective but opt for PVC-free or phthalate-free versions.
  • AAP Recommendation: Use flannel-backed waterproof covers for comfort and safety.

2. Breathable Mattresses

  • Marketed for reduced overheating and "rebreathing" risk (linked to SIDS).
  • AAP Stance: No proven benefits, but they’re safe if firm and fit snugly.

3. Organic and Natural Options

  • Certifications to Look For:
  • Greenguard Gold: Limits chemical emissions.
  • CertiPUR-US: Tests for formaldehyde and heavy metals.
  • GOTS: Requires 95% organic material and prohibits harmful chemicals.
  • GOLS: Certifies latex content as organic.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Use a Waterproof Cover: Prevents liquids from reaching the mattress.

Spot Clean: For spills, use soap and water.

Wash Covers Regularly: Follow manufacturer’s instructions (some are machine washable).

Avoid Harsh Chemicals: Stick to gentle cleaning products to protect the cover’s waterproof layer.


Popular Brands

Babyletto: Mid- to high-priced crib mattresses with a focus on infant safety. - babyletto.com

Colgate Kids: Offers innerspring and natural crib mattresses with a focus on durability. - colgatekids.com

Naturepedic: Specializes in organic crib mattresses made with safe, non-toxic materials. - naturepedic.com

Newton Baby: Known for innovative, breathable mattresses with washable covers. - newtonbaby.com

Sealy/Kolcraft: Trusted for affordable and durable crib mattresses. - sealy.com


Pro Tips

  • Replace mattresses that lose firmness or show signs of wear.
  • Always use snugly fitted sheets to maintain a safe sleeping environment.
  • Check the mattress label or manufacturer’s instructions for specific maintenance guidelines.

By focusing on safety, fit, and firmness, you’ll create a secure and comfortable sleeping space for your baby.


Next: Read 2500+ consumer guides to shopping, electronics, appliances, home services, cars, money and more.
If you liked all this, consider supporting us by checking out Tiny Skills - 250+ Top Work & Personal Skills Made Easy

The Success Manuals


The Career Advice Bible

100+ Most Important Career Questions
Finally Answered

318 Pages | $5 | PDF & EPub, Kindle Ready

250 Top Work & Personal Skills Made Easy

The First & Only Encyclopedia of Self Help,
Self Improvement & Career Advice

250+ Easy-to-Follow Guides
5000+ Proven Tips

13 Types of Essential Skills Covered
Get The Value of 100+ Best Books in 1 Book.

502 Pages | $5 | PDF / EPub, Kindle Ready