Best Siding Buying Guide

On February 25, 2026 By newsroom Topic: Household Needs Buyers Guide

New siding is a costly home upgrade but can significantly enhance curb appeal and offer a high return on investment. Choosing the right siding material and installation method is crucial for durability, aesthetics, and long-term satisfaction.

Key Considerations Before Buying Siding

Return on Investment (ROI):
Vinyl siding: Recoups ~94.7% of its cost at resale.
Fiber cement siding: Recoups ~88.5%.
Cost:
Average cost for vinyl: $16,000+.
Average cost for fiber cement: $19,000+.
Performance Factors:
Resistance to impact, wind, and UV light varies significantly by material and brand.

How Experts Test Siding

Color Change:
- Samples are exposed to UV light to simulate long-term sun exposure.

Impact Resistance:
- Tested at 0°F and 70°F by dropping weights on overlapping panels.

Wind Resistance:
- Siding is subjected to simulated winds over 150 mph.

Types of Siding and Their Features

1. Vinyl Siding
- Pros:
- Affordable and low-maintenance.
- Resistant to water, warping, and insects.
- Cons:
- Can crack, rattle, and fade under UV light.
- Less realistic wood appearance up close.

2. Plastic Siding
- Pros:
- Closely resembles cedar, even up close.
- Requires minimal maintenance.
- Cons:
- Thicker and 2–3 times more expensive than vinyl.

3. Fiber Cement Siding (e.g., Hardie Plank)
- Pros:
- Most realistic wood look.
- Fireproof and insect-proof.
- Available factory-primed or pre-painted for long-lasting finishes.
- Cons:
- Vulnerable to water damage during freeze-thaw cycles.
- Requires periodic refinishing.

4. Wood Siding
- Pros:
- Offers classic, traditional charm.
- Resistant to impact.
- Cons:
- Expensive and requires regular maintenance.
- Prone to rot, insect damage, and warping.

Installation Tips

Remove Old Siding First:
- Reveals hidden damage and prevents an odd "inset" look for windows and doors.

Use Certified Installers:
- Look for contractors certified by the Vinyl Siding Institute (VSI) or manufacturer recommendations.

Compare Quotes:
- Speak to at least three contractors. Request all-inclusive estimates covering materials, labor, and disposal.

Inspect Workmanship Warranties:
- Ensure the warranty details what’s covered and for how long (ranges from one year to a lifetime).

Maintaining Your Siding

Prevent Water Damage:
- Seal joints around windows, doors, and corners with caulk.
- Check for water stains under eaves in winter (signs of ice damming).

Clean Regularly:
- Use soapy water and a soft brush. Avoid pressure washing into gaps to prevent moisture buildup.

Protect from Mold:
- Ensure siding allows water to drain properly to avoid mold and rot.

Additional Features to Consider

Insulation: Foam-backed vinyl adds rigidity and energy efficiency.
Seamless Panels: Longer vinyl panels reduce visible seams on large walls.
Durability Enhancements: Double-layer mounting hems provide better wind resistance.

Siding Cost Estimates

Labor Costs: $5,000–$15,000 for a 2,500 sq. ft. home.
Material Prices per Square (100 sq. ft.):
Vinyl: $2–$7.
Plastic: $6–$12.
Fiber Cement: $5–$10.
Wood: $6–$10 (clapboard) and higher for shingles.

Investing in quality siding and proper installation ensures long-term performance, aesthetics, and value.