Bathtub Refinishing vs. Liner: What’s Right for Your Home?

On February 16, 2025 By newsroom Topic: Home Services

1. Bathtub Liners

What It Is:
A molded acrylic or PVC liner placed over your existing tub for a refreshed appearance.

Installation Process:
- Measure tub and create a custom liner mold.
- Remove hardware and prepare the tub with adhesive and caulking.
- Attach the liner snugly.
- Time: ~6 hours; tub usable the same night.

Cost:
- $1,100–$1,400

Lifespan:
- 3–5 years (risk of mold or mildew forming underneath).

Cleaning:
- Handles abrasive cleaners easily, making maintenance simpler.

Pros:
- Quick, straightforward installation.
- Durable and easy to clean.
- Less intensive than refinishing.

Cons:
- Higher upfront cost than refinishing.
- Shorter lifespan (potential mold/mildew buildup).

2. Bathtub Refinishing

What It Is:
A process of reglazing the tub's surface using layers of epoxy and sealant for a new look.

Installation Process:
- Cover non-refinishing areas with protective sheeting.
- Remove old caulking and apply hydrofluoric acid to prep the tub.
- Add multiple coats of epoxy and polyurethane.
- Sand and polish for a smooth finish.
- Time: ~6 hours; tub usable after 24 hours.

Cost:
- $450

Lifespan:
- 10–15 years with proper care.

Cleaning:
- Avoid abrasive cleaners; clean weekly to extend the glaze’s longevity.

Pros:
- Affordable and long-lasting.
- Offers color and sheen customization.
- Refreshes without replacing.

Cons:
- Can’t use the tub for 24 hours.
- Requires professional handling due to hazardous chemicals.
- More frequent cleaning needed to maintain the finish.

Comparison: Liner vs. Refinishing

| Feature | Liner | Refinishing |
|--------------------|----------------------------|-----------------------------|
| Cost | $1,100–$1,400 | $450 |
| Lifespan | 3–5 years | 10–15 years |
| Ease of Cleaning | Easy; abrasive cleaners OK | Requires gentle cleaning |
| Installation Time | 6 hours (usable same day) | 6 hours (usable in 24 hours)|
| DIY Feasibility | Possible (with kit) | Difficult; professional recommended |

Best Option for Your Home

Choose a liner if:
You want a quick update and prefer easy maintenance.
You're okay with a shorter lifespan.
Choose refinishing if:
You’re on a budget and want a long-lasting solution.
You prefer a customized appearance.

Alternatives to Consider:

New Tub:
Cost: $1,400–$7,000 (depending on materials and installation).
Offers a full reset but at a higher cost.
DIY Repainting:
Use epoxy-based paint for an affordable refresh.
Acrylic Tub Surrounds:
Quick, budget-friendly way to upgrade your bathroom’s look.

Pro Tip: Consult with a bathroom remodeling professional to assess the condition of your tub and determine the best option!